Evanger's Dog Food has a mixed reputation. While some users appreciate the quality of ingredients and variety of options, there are concerns about the company's history of recalls and transparency issues. The average rating on some review sites is around 2.3 stars.
The company has faced FDA scrutiny and had its manufacturing plant shut down in 2008 due to expired operating permits. Additionally, the owners were charged with stealing $2 million in utilities for their company.
Overall, the legitimacy of evangersdogfood.com is questionable due to these controversies and mixed reviews.