BestBullySticks.com has mixed reviews from customers. Some users praise the quality of the products and the prompt service, while others have reported issues with customer service and product consistency. The company has a rating of 2.3 on Yelp and 1.9 on Trustpilot, indicating a range of experiences. Some customers have had positive experiences with the quality and bulk availability of the products, while others have faced problems with broken teeth in their pets and misleading product descriptions.
Overall, the legitimacy of BestBullySticks.com seems to depend on individual experiences, with some customers satisfied and others disappointed.