BakeMeAWish.com is generally considered legit based on customer reviews. The company has an average rating of 3.4 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot, with over 9,100 reviews. Many customers praise the excellent customer service and timely delivery of their orders. However, there are some negative reviews regarding the quality of certain products and delivery issues. Overall, the majority of customers seem satisfied with their experience, indicating that BakeMeAWish.com is a legitimate service for ordering gourmet cakes and gifts.