Steiner Sports is generally considered legit. The website has a rating of 4.1 stars on Trustpilot and 4.2 stars on Sitejabber, indicating that most customers are satisfied with their purchases. Positive reviews often mention good customer service and satisfactory product quality. However, there are some negative reviews about delayed refunds and incorrect items being shipped.
Overall, Steiner Sports appears to be a reliable site for sports memorabilia, but it's always good to read recent reviews and contact customer service for any specific concerns.